blog 
The Constitution: Just a Piece of Paper
According to a few sources, President Bush angrily opposed any mention of the Constitution when he and others were gathered together to brainstorm how best to trample the document, calling it just a “piece of paper” (the actual quote containing some more colorful language). When reports of this exchange were published, many were justifiably shocked and appalled at the behavior of a man who has publicly sworn to uphold and defend the Constitution.
But while such behavior is repulsive and tyrannical, Bush was right—the Constitution is just a piece of paper.
The Constitution is a contract that exists between “we the people” and our federal government. In reality, the document itself is nothing more than a collection of much-debated words scrawled on parchment. It is a historical wonder and a great collector’s item, but at the end of the day, it’s just a paper with words on it.
Like any other set of words, the Constitution only has power if the value we apply to the words leads us to honor and fulfill their meaning. A contract between two people that nobody enforces is worth nothing more than the sheet of paper upon which it is written. Likewise, without a group of people who respect and implement the Constitutional contract created by the words found on the document, its only value is that of the price it will fetch at a collector’s auction.
Ignoring the Constitution—an action which happens more often that not in Washington, D.C.—renders null and void any attempt to establish authority and restraint on power. Without a willing and authorized party to enforce its provisions and ensure they are obeyed, the document serves no purpose and transforms itself into historical eye candy.
With leaders like President Bush in power, and a cowardly and complicit Congress and Supreme Court, the checks and balances created by the document fade into oblivion and leave us with a piece of paper. Bush was right: our failure to enforce the contract created by the Constitution has resulted in it being treated as little more than the animal parchment and ink used to create it.
***************
Related Posts (automatically generated)
- Orrin Hatch: The Constitution is Hanging By a Thread
- Utah Senator Bob Bennett is No Friend of the Constitution
- Domestic Enemies of the Constitution
- Constitution, Conscience, Constituency
- The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
13 comments so far. Care to chime in?
#1 Kelly W. | December 1st, 2008 10:50 AM“But while such behavior is repulsive and tyrannical, Bush was right—the Constitution is just a piece of paper.”
But Connor, the Constitution is a “God-inspired” piece of paper, not a “G__ D_____” piece of paper as Bush called it.
How Mormons can like a president who uses profanity at the Constitution is beyond me. Utahns gave Bush his largest margins in the 2004 election.
When the Constitution hangs by a thread, we probably won’t be able to count on the Republican Elders to save it.
#2 Reach Upward | December 1st, 2008 12:02 PMIsn’t it odd how, unlike every other legal document, our judiciary considers ‘modern interpretations’ of the words in the document and ‘changing cultural values’ when interpreting what constitutes constitutional.
“…and they saw that their laws had become corrupted, and that they had become a wicked people….” (Helaman 4:22)
#3 rmwarnick | December 1st, 2008 12:47 PMIt is the responsibility of Congress to impeach President Bush for violating the Constitution. They could still do it, but probably won’t because, as you say, most members of Congress have no more respect for the Constitution than Bush does.
It will be interesting to see how much our next President can do or will try to do to restore the rule of law.
#4 Frank Staheli | December 1st, 2008 1:25 PMSpeaking of respect for “The Piece of Paper”, how about the insult that was added to the injury of Obama likely not being a United States Citizen–apparently Hillary Clinton cannot constitutionally become Secretary of State.
#5 Clumpy | December 1st, 2008 1:50 PM@Kelly:
Because we’re morons who haven’t really considered what we believe. Bush was too stubborn and loved being the “decider” too much to ever let anything including morality (except professed morality) dictate his behavior, and we let him do it because of the manufactured “culture war” that kept us from moving to the other side or, better yet, forming our own opinions of individual issues and developing a larger philosophy.
These articles confirm what I knew about Bush for so long. I just never knew he verbalized it. How sad.
#6 Kelly W. | December 1st, 2008 3:24 PMFrank,
It sure does appear Obama wasn’t born in Hawaii. However, this breach of the Constitution pales in comparison with what Cheney and Bush has done the past 8 years.
We gave McCain a pass, apparently, because it is fact that McCain was born in Panama.
#7 David | December 1st, 2008 3:33 PMConnor,
I think you give Congress too much credit by saying they are “cowardly and complicit.” Our Congress has been as active in shredding the foundation of our government as the president has been.
@Reach
Personally I like this quote – “they were a stiffnecked people, insomuch that they could not be governed by the law nor justice, save it were to their destruction.” (Helaman 5:3)
#10 Lili | December 1st, 2008 4:20 PM(Ok, now I feel a need to back up my statement:
According to Wiki answers, it was drafted on paper, but the one that was signed was parchment (animal skin–also called vellum)
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_kind_of_paper_or_parchment_was_the_US_constitution_written_on
#11 Dara | December 4th, 2008 2:27 PMour failure to enforce the contract created by the Constitution has resulted in it being treated as little more than the animal parchment
Exactly correct. It’s practically become null and void with the way the past couple administrations have practically ignored the document. It angers me that it’s treated with such contempt and disregard.
#12 The Mike | December 6th, 2008 12:01 AMGreat post – as usual. Just a piece of paper indeed, but the government it forms is definitely more influential to freedom, tangible to individuals and all around principally sound. That’s one thing that cannot be brushed aside like they do the document itself – not for long at least, and oh how I rue that day.
#13 Carborendum | December 6th, 2008 8:14 PMIt has been disregarded since George Washington’s presidency. People in power applied what they understood, but twisted it to mean whatever they wanted it to mean to serve their aims. Even Washington was no exception. And he was among those to draft the thing.
The difference today is that we have no power to correct anything from previous administrations. We used to have representation in Congress. The House of Representatives was beholden to the people. Today they are not. The way things have become structured has made it impossible for the average citizen to have a voice at all.
Post a comment
what's new
Featuring 748 posts w/ 11,437 comments.
Search the blog
Media/Events
- 3/13/09 Talk radio guest appearance
- 2/9/09 Talk radio guest appearance
- 12/21/09 Op-ed, Daily Herald
- 12/2/09 Op-ed, Deseret News
- 11/18/09 Lecture, Young Americans for Liberty UVU Chapter
- 11/5/09 Op-ed, Salt Lake Tribune
- 9/16/09 Op-ed, Daily Herald
- 9/4/09 Talk radio guest appearance
Recent Comments 
- Connor on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Alyssa on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- THOMAS DYCHES on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Connor on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Jim Davis on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Jim Davis on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- rmwarnick on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Jim Davis on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- John M on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- rmwarnick on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Paula N. on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- THOMAS DYCHES on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- THOMAS DYCHES on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Sean on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Connor on The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- View extended list »
Most Commented
- Why Do Latter-day Saints Ignore Ron Paul? (332)
- Why I’m For Ron Paul and Against Mitt Romney (263)
- Religion and Politics: The LDS Church and Proposition 8 (165)
- Outrage Over a Shoe (153)
- The Protected Class of Sexuality (152)
- Breaking: New Anti-Proposition 8 Campaign to Target LDS Church President Thomas S. Monson (152)
- Council on Foreign Relations (125)
- Glenn Beck’s Broad Brush (125)
- FLDS Petition Conclusion (121)
- Brigham Young on Public Education (118)
- Domestic Enemies of the Constitution (116)
- Harry Reid Against the “Right Wingers” (115)
- Health Care Hocus Pocus (115)
- Media Blacklisting Ron Paul (110)
- On President Hinckley’s “War and Peace” (106)
- Monarchial Remnants (103)
- The Rights of an Embryo (103)
- Some Questions on 9/11 (96)
- A New Year for Patriotism (89)
- Constitutional Questions (85)
- View extended list »
Recent Posts
- The Census, the Constitution, and Civil Disobedience
- Enforcing the Law on Law Enforcement
- The Unwarranted Expansion of Administrative Subpoenas in Utah
- Why America Should Apologize
- On the Necessity of Repentance
- The Arrogance of America's Aristocracy
- Constitution, Conscience, Constituency
- On Amendments and Constitutional Purity
- The Misplaced Ire of Citizens United
- Why the Latter-day Saints Prepare
- The Failure of Foreign Aid
- Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness... Unless You're in Utero
- Utah Senator Bob Bennett is No Friend of the Constitution
- On Whether to Tear Down or Build Up
- The Redemption of the Republicans
- The Criminalization of the Citizenry
- Punishing the Many to Protect the Few
- A New Year for Patriotism
- GOED: Redistributing Utah's Wealth
- The Hyper-Sexual Indoctrination of Children
- View extended list »
Church Talks
- On the Necessity of Repentance
- Why the Latter-day Saints Prepare
- The Family: A Proclamation to the World
- For the Strength of Youth—Service to Others
- For the Strength of Youth—Honesty
- For the Strength of Youth—Music and Dance
- For the Strength of Youth—Entertainment and Media
- For the Strength of Youth—Family
- Inviting the Savior Into Our Home Through Worship
- Gratitude
Aaaaarchives
- March 2010 (3)
- February 2010 (6)
- January 2010 (7)
- December 2009 (8)
- November 2009 (8)
- October 2009 (7)
- September 2009 (8)
- August 2009 (6)
- July 2009 (8)
- June 2009 (6)
- May 2009 (8)
- April 2009 (7)
- March 2009 (8)
- February 2009 (8)
- January 2009 (10)
- December 2008 (10)
- November 2008 (12)
- October 2008 (13)
- September 2008 (10)
- August 2008 (8)
- July 2008 (9)
- June 2008 (10)
- May 2008 (7)
- April 2008 (9)
- March 2008 (12)
- February 2008 (10)
- January 2008 (11)
- December 2007 (11)
- November 2007 (14)
- October 2007 (12)
- September 2007 (10)
- August 2007 (20)
- July 2007 (7)
- June 2007 (13)
- May 2007 (21)
- April 2007 (23)
- March 2007 (26)
- February 2007 (23)
- January 2007 (29)
- December 2006 (33)
- November 2006 (55)
- October 2006 (62)
- September 2006 (27)
- August 2006 (32)
- July 2006 (68)
- June 2006 (26)
featured shtuff
PORTFOLIO
Web/print design and development (and other stuff!), done right.
MIKE LEE
Restoring the founding principles of our Constitution.
QUOTY
Save and tag your favorite quotes, and share w/ your friends!
BOOK OF MORMON
Join Elder Holland in declaring your witness to the world!
UTAH PREPPERS
Preparing Deseret, one blogger at a time.
LEADERSHIP EDUCATION
To build men and women of virtue, wisdom, diplomacy, and courage who inspire greatness in others and move the cause of liberty.
POLITICAL RESTORATION
Restore the Republic! Join the Ron Paul Campaign for Liberty.
BOOK LIST
Here's what I'm currently reading.














